Although ricoeur developed his theory of narrative with literary novels in mind, i would argue that it can also be read as a theory of religion, and as a theory of popular culture. In ricoeurs project, textinterpretation turns out 10 bc thc paradigm ior in general, and hence his focus on thc hermeneutics of the text. Time and narrative is the finest example of contemporary philosophical hermeneutics and is one of the most significant works of. Paul ricoeur s study of the intertwining of time and narrative proposes and examines the possibility that narrative could remedy a fatal deficiency in any purely phenomenological approach. Pdf with notable exceptions, the organization studies literature has tended to. This paper attempts to engage critically with ricoeurs multifaceted and multilayered approach to history. In 2000, he was awarded the kyoto prize in arts and. Narrative interviewing and narrative analysis in a study. Charles taylor and paul ricoeur on selfinterpretations and narrative identity in this chapter i discuss charles taylors and paul ricoeur s theories of narrative identity and narratives as a central form of selfinterpretation. Arto laitinen, charles taylor and paul ricoeur on self. Access to this document requires a subscription or membership. Ricoeurs theory of narrative as a theory of popular cultural. Paul ricoeur some years ago at an institute for advanced studies in the humanities. Paul ricoeur s theory of narrative has implications for a wide spectrum of contemporary thought.
Drawing upon ricoeurs conception of narrative identity, an analytic. The essays, including three pieces by ricoeur himself, consider this important study, extending and developing the debate it has inspired. It is this interplay between the story and reader as developed by paul ricoeur that i want to reflect on in this paper. May 25, 2017 narrative identity and a poetics of the self. However, this basic attribute leads me in a different direction regarding the preferred focus for future research on identity and. Paul ricoeur and narrative identity psychology today. Ricoeur, paul freud and philosophy essay on interpretation. Narrative and narrative identity in his magnificent three volume work time and narrative 198488, ricoeur. Narrative time in the name of the rose time is intrinsically tied to umberto ecos the name of the rose. Ricoeur on time and narrative presents that argument in clear and concise terms, in a way that will be enlightening both to readers new to ricoeur and those who may have felt themselves adrift in the complexities of temps et recit, ricoeurs last major philosophical work. French philosopher paul ricoeur 192005 developed an account of narrative and narrative identity that has been highly influential.
According to ricoeur, narrative identity is characterized by the dialectic of sameness and selfhood. Paul ricoeur on refigurative reading and narrative identity. First, this is done through the explication of the concept in the framework of narrative approach. Constructing and reconstructing narrative identity lucius. Narrative patterns, therefore, are communicated, but they are also transformed in their application to specific instances. Time and narrative builds on paul ricoeurs earlier analysis, in the rule of metaphor, of semantic innovation at the level of the sentence. For anyone used to the straightforward arguments of analytic philosophy, i found, the best way to see what ricoeur was doing was to ignore the occasional glimpses of aporia or paradox in the remote dis. Paul ricoeur 192005 is widely recognized as one of the most. I also will differentiate between different narrative approaches, comment on their merits and shortcomings, and therewith try to push narrative analysis toward a more comprehensive approach. Stages of a long philosophical itinerary fonds ricoeur. Paul ricoeur stanford encyclopedia of philosophywinter 2014. Jun 04, 20 narrative identity is a persons internalized and evolving life story, integrating the reconstructed past and imagined future to provide life with some degree of unity and purpose. The identity of an individual or a character in a narrative is his or her narrative identity.
This final volume, a comprehensive reexamination and synthesis of the ideas developed in volumes 1 and 2, stands as ricoeurs most complete and satisfying presentation of his own. Pdf charles taylor and paul ricoeur on selfinterpretations and. This article introduces narrative interviewing and narrative analysis as qualitative methods relevant to international business research. Explanation and understanding, in from text to action. Ricoeur was then in the early stages of writing time and narrative, and was concentrating on the work of northrop frye and hayden white. Charles taylor and paul ricoeur on selfinterpretations and narrative identity. The research work done by the author investigates a phenomenological fieldthe subjective experience of chronic illness and disabilityby means of a specific research instrument, the autobiographical narrative interview. Its main endeavor is to expose what ricoeur means by an identity that springs from the fusion. Personal identity terapia cognitiva postrazionalista.
He analysed both literary and historical writing, from proust to braudel, as well as key figures in the history of philosophy. In this chapter i discuss charles taylors and paul ricoeurs theories of narrative identity and narratives as a central form of selfinterpretation. Narrative is a cognitive instrument which conveys social articulations of identity. Ricoeur finds a healthy circle between time and narrative. Ricoeurs analysis of temporal configurations in time and narrative, of the interpenetration of history and fiction in any narrative representation, is perhaps the major contemporary theoretical statement in this line of thought. Narrative identity and meaning making across the adult lifespan.
What is at stake is the possibility of a phenomenological hermeneutics as a critique of and at the same time an improvement. Charles taylor and paul ricoeur on selfinterpretations. While the work of paul ricoeur ranges over diverse subjects the problem of evil, the meaning of identity, human will, and human fragility his philosophical writings have increasingly centered on hermeneutics as the key instrument in the search for meaning. Ricoeurs theory of narrative as a theory of popular cultural religion. However, there are important differences in the way the relationship between narrative, identity and political philosophy is conceived. These scholars have investigated a number of issues that intersect with narrative theology, including morality, truth. This paper will primarily be devoted to the concept of narrative identity as developed by one of the great thinkers of our contemporary era, paul ricoeur. Time amd narrative volume i paul ricoeur translated by kathleen mclaughlin and david pellauer paul ricoeur has been the dean of the faculty of letters and human sciences at the university of paris x nantcrrc for many years and is currently the john nuveen professor emeritus in the divinity school, the department of philosophy, and the. Ricoeurs theory of narrative as a theory of popular. Both taylor and ricoeur think that selfidentity is a matter of culturally and socially mediated selfdefinitions, which are practically relevant for ones orientation in life. The purpose of this paper is to demonstrate the contribution of paul ricoeurs narrative theory to social events studies. The novel consists of several parts that attempt to bring a.
In this sense reality is interwoven with narrative fictions. Narratives are important tools in constructing an organization, and individual and collective narratives about key actors and critical events compete in defining the organization and making sense of the challenges faced in organizational change processes. Ricoeur proposes a theoretical model of this circle using augustines theory of time and aristotles theory of plot and, further, develops an original thesis of the mimetic function of narrative. Narrative identity and meaning making across the adult. Autobiographical memory and the art of storytelling and. That is, we piece together our identities through the narration of a life story. This book examines the later work of paul ricoeur, particularly his major work, time and narrative. In the first two volumes of this work, paul ricoeur examined the relations between time and narrative in historical writing, fiction, and theories of literature.
On paul ricoeur narrative and interpretation taylor. Paul ricoeurs interest in phenomenology will leave its mark on the method he practiced in his first major work, freedom and nature. These memories perform a selfrepresentative function by using personal memories to create and maintain a coherent selfidentity, or narrative identity, over time. Thompson, northwestern up, evanston, 1991 106 ricoeur, interpretation theory. Paul ricoeur 192005 was a distinguished french philosopher of the twentieth century, one whose work has been widely translated and discussed across the world. In philosophical hermeneutics and theology, he points out that his objective hermeneutics based on the problematics or the text. In each case i want to consider what the focus on narrative contributes to understanding identity and what it offers political philosophy. This is the place of the dialectic between identity idem and identity ipse which arises from the second grammatical trait of soimeme oneself and the ambiguity of the word meme same. I also began, on my own, to read ricoeurs previously published works.
Ricoeurs examination ofhusserls, kants, and heideggers treatments of time finds inadequaciesindeed aporiasin each. Charles taylor and paul ricoeur on selfinterpretations and narrative identity chapter pdf available january 2002 with 1,731 reads how we measure reads. Narrative identity is mainly concerned with autobiographical memories and often are influenced by the meaning and emotions the individual has assigned to that event. Time and narrative is the finest example of contemporary philosophical hermeneutics and is one of the most significant works of this book examines the later work of paul ricoeur, particularly his major work. The narrative identity in paul ricoeurs hermeneutics of the self. In the novel umberto eco presents a unique account of times place within narration. Ricoeur, philosophical hermeneutics and theology, theology digest, 24.
A character in a narrative is an individual who may be reidentified as being the same. As such, his thought is within the same tradition as other major hermeneutic phenomenologists, edmund husserl and hansgeorg gadamer. Ricoeur here examines the creation of meaning at the textual level, with narrative rather than metaphor as the ruling concern. These two possibilities merge in the act of reading, which ricoeur will also invoke in his. Philosophers writing on time, too, usually over look the contribution of narrative to a critique of the concept of time. The narrative constructs the identity of the character, what can be. Paul ricoeur narrative identity free download as pdf file. In ricoeurs theory, prenarrative lived structures mimesis 1 provoke the configuration of a narrative textworld mimesis 2 that is inhabited by reading, and the effects spill out into the everyday world, having a decisive impact upon the identity and perspective of the reader mimesis 3. This example of narrative identity brings the practice of autobiography to mind. Each act of communication involves to a greater or lesser extent an act of interpretation and reconfiguration. Paul ricoeur and the theory of narrative identity article in allgemeine zeitschrift fur philosophie 383. Narrative, identity and modernity discussion paper for ecpr workshop the political uses of narrative mannheim, 2931 march, 1999 susan stephenson department of politics university of edinburgh email.
What actuauy mediates between phenomenological and cosmological time, ricoeur argues, is historical time, understood as a reinscription oflived time on cosmic time p. Charles taylor and paul ricoeur on selfinterpretations and. In time and narrative, he moves to the level higher than the sentenceto plotbut he is still concerned with semantics, and, as opposed to structuralist theorists of narrative who have. The problem of an events definition and distinction is still at stake in sociological debates. Topics freud, ricoeur, ermeneutics, psychoanalysis collection. Narrative identity is a persons internalized and evolving life story, integrating the reconstructed past and imagined future to provide life with some degree of unity and purpose. According to the narrative view of personal identity, as theorized by thinkers such as marya schectman and alasdair macintyre, 19 identity is constructed through the narrative composition of autobiographical memory. Paul ricoeur narrative identity hermeneutics philosophical. Narrative interviewing and narrative analysis in a study of a. Review edi pucci 1992 philosophy and social criticism 18 2. However, of the seven references to autobiography in time and narrative the only ones to have a bearing on the concept of narrative identity are two references that undermine it. Start your 48hour free trial to unlock this time and narrative study guide and get instant access to the following analysis. View narrative identity research papers on academia. Narration and its contribution to self and identity michael bamberg clark university abstract this article critically examines the recent turn to narratives as tools for identity construction and identity analysis.
Ricoeur dreams initially about the possibility of a hermeneutic phenomenology, a project already begun by heidegger and continued later by gadamer in the tradition of german philosophy. In this chapter i discuss charles taylors and paul ricoeur s theories of narrative identity and narratives as a central form of selfinterpretation. Paul ricoeurs oneself as another 1992 is based on the gifford lectures which he delivered at the university of edinburgh in 1986. Drawing on a vast number of philosophical, historical and sociological works, ricoeurs hermeneutics develops as an invaluable corpus of writings on virtually all the aspects of history and historicity alike. Constructing and reconstructing narrative identity. These memories perform a selfrepresentative function by using personal memories to create and maintain a coherent self identity, or narrative identity, over time. Paul ricoeurs theory of narrative has implications for a wide spectrum of contemporary thought. Both taylor and ricoeur think that self identity is a matter of culturally and socially mediated selfdefinitions, which are practically relevant for ones orientation in life.
Pdf the narrative identity in paul ricoeurs hermeneutics of the. In addition to his academic work, his public presence as a social and political commentator, particularly in france, led to a square in paris being named in his honor on the. Here ricoeur links narrative identity with the philosophy of action, since narrative is the imitation of action mimesis. Personal identity, narrative identity and selfhood in the thought of paul ricoeur. This final volume, a comprehensive reexamination and synthesis of the ideas developed in volumes 1 and 2, stands as ricoeur s most complete and satisfying presentation of his own. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Charles taylor and paul ricoeur on selfinterpretations and narrative identity in this chapter i discuss charles taylors and paul ricoeurs theories of narrative identity and narratives as a central form of selfinterpretation.
Its organizing concern is how individuals employ narratives to develop and. This article introduces narrative interviewing and narrative analysis as qualitative methods relevant to international. This collection of essays explores many of the areas to which his narrative strategies can be fruitfully applied, including architecture, psychology, psychoanalysis, feminist theory, ethics, sociology, medieval and contemporary literature, and religious studies. The lectures examine the meaning of personal identity, and explore the relation between identity and selfhood. Personal identity, narrative identity, and selfhood in the thought of paul ricoeur philosophy and social criticism 18 1992, pp. Singer department of psychology, connecticut college in a quiet but consistent way, a new subdiscipline of personality psychologynarrative identity researchhas emerged.
447 821 1426 1532 750 923 462 1034 778 231 914 531 34 1502 598 375 296 1132 1493 1088 1088 713 543 820 1090 11 488 916 561